If you’re in the healthcare industry, you know that everything you do regarding ePHI (electronic protected health information) begins and ends with HIPAA compliance. HIPAA requires the implementation of many security protocols to ensure the confidentiality, integrity, and availability of ePHI. While HIPAA rules do not specifically require penetration testing, it’s a foundational security component. This post defines HIPAA penetration testing, its benefits, and how it can differ from standard ones.
What Is HIPAA Penetration Testing?
Penetration testing describes simulated cyberattacks. A third party you engage will carry this out to identify vulnerabilities in your network that cybercriminals can exploit. With a HIPAA penetration test, the simulation’s focus aligns with the HIPAA Security Rule, the HIPAA Privacy Rule, and the Breach Notification Rule. Ethical hacking can test your networks, applications, and additional security components.
How Are HIPAA Penetration Tests Different from Standard Ones?
Conducting a HIPAA penetration test involves most of the same elements. The key differences relate to ePHI. Such a test for a healthcare entity aims to determine where weaknesses exist regarding breaching ePHI. The test parameters should include the guidelines in the rules noted above. Here’s some more information on each.
Pen Testing and the HIPAA Security Rule
The HIPAA Security Rule defines practices for protecting the confidentiality, accessibility, and integrity of PHI. Again, the rule doesn’t require pen testing, but it does require the development of risk management capabilities, which typically include a HIPAA security risk analysis.
Related to this analysis, HHS (Health and Human Services) and OCR (Office for Civil Rights), whose duty is to enforce HIPAA, provides five major points you’ll need to consider and can support your healthcare pen test.
- You need to assess all risks and vulnerabilities regarding the confidentiality, integrity, and availability of ePHI.
- Your organization must regularly review how they are complying with HIPAA.
- You must identify how you create, receive, maintain, and transmit ePHI.
- Your business must determine how vendors and third parties with access to ePHI can create, receive, maintain, and transmit ePHI.
- You will need to define all threats relating to data security. It should involve risk in three categories: human (internal and external), natural (hurricanes, flooding, earthquakes, etc.), and environmental (physical and cyber).
These guidelines and administrative, physical, and technical safeguards from the HIPAA Security Rule align with what a pen test can reveal.
Pen Testing and the HIPAA Privacy Rule
The HIPAA Privacy Rule sets standards for protecting PHI. The rule focuses on data privacy and documenting how to use and disclose such data. Pen testing is associated with anything you can identify that compromises privacy. It’s not simply about determining if someone can breach your system and steal data. A pen test may find irregularities in your internal processes that might impact privacy.
Pen Testing and the Breach Notification Rule
This segment of HIPAA is what happens should a breach occur. It discusses all the types of notices you must facilitate. It would be best if you had a policy on how you’ll handle breach notifications. While this rule doesn’t relate to data security protocols and vulnerabilities assessed in a pen test, it can be part of your simulation. When you receive your pen test analysis and identify a breach that could have occurred, you could role-play how you’ll launch notifications to test out the accuracy of your procedures.
Beyond the rules, there are some other differences in a HIPAA pen test:
- HHS specifies 18 identifiers that change general healthcare information to PHI. Testers should understand these.
- Data may be anonymized or de-identified but still should be part of the pen test.
- Unique technology applications have special security considerations because of how they use or embed data.
- Testers should be familiar with the FHIR API used in many healthcare applications. Checking these implementations is critical to ensure random access to PHI.
Designing Your HIPAA Pen Tests: Access, Testing Methods, and Types
When deciding to engage in pen testing to ensure HIPAA compliance, you have many options in frameworks related to access levels, methods, and types.
Access Levels
First, you’ll determine the level of access you’ll give the testers. There are three levels:
- Black Box Penetration Testing, also known as Opaque Box, is a scenario in which the hackers have no information about your organization’s systems or internal structure. This option gives you a real-world view of how a cybercriminal would seek to breach your network.
- Gray Box Penetration Testing, also known as Semi-Opaque Box: Testers know something about your systems and network in this situation. They may also have credentials, and the test could involve specific test cases like an attempt to breach ePHI in an application.
- White Box Penetration Testing, also known as Transparent Box, is a setting in which testers have access to systems, artifacts, and possibly servers. The White Box can simulate an internal attack.
Testing Methods
In addition to access levels, different pen testing methods exist. Here’s how they could play out in the context of HIPAA.
- External testing. A tester targets visible assets of your organization — web apps, websites, email, domain name servers, etc. The goal is to use these assets to gain access to your network and extract ePHI.
- Internal testing. A tester enters the network behind the firewall to depict the consequences of human error or stolen credentials through phishing.
- Blind testing. A tester knows only your business name and, from there, begins a quest to find weaknesses. It’s a good option for a real-time view of application assaults.
- Double-blind testing. Your internal security team is unaware that pen testing is occurring. They would respond immediately to the threat, believing it to be legitimate.
- Targeted testing. Testers and your technical staff collaborate to simulate and react to an attack.
Pen Test Types
Next, you’ll consider what part of your IT infrastructure to test. In terms of HIPAA pen tests, you’ll want to test the following:
- Web applications. How secure are the apps you use daily to manage, handle, transmit, and store ePHI?
- Network security. How secure are your routers, switches, and network hosts? Are they configured correctly?
- Cloud security. If you use the cloud, which you probably do, how secure is your cloud, and are there weaknesses present?
Getting the Most Value from HIPAA Penetration Testing
You will need to make appropriate design decisions during your HIPAA penetration test. In addition to these components, what will make your pen test most valuable in securing your organization?
- Set goals for your pen test. Determine what you believe the pen test will uncover. If applicable, look back to previous tests to confirm whether the corrective action was successful.
- Work with a pen testing firm with healthcare expertise. Pen testing is a commodity in the IT market. Many people can conduct it, but you should seek out an organization specializing in healthcare pen tests. Healthcare is unique, and you need a partner who understands this.
- Opt for multiple testing formats. Your testers will need to conduct different types of tests and use many methods to discern your compliance with HIPAA and potential weaknesses.
- Define the scope of your test. Every pen test is different, as it should be. Your healthcare data environment is distinctly your own, consisting of many components. Part of this scope is selecting the types and methods. The other part is talking about testing ranges, comprehensive approaches, and scenarios vital to the security of ePHI.
- Document the Rules of Engagement (ROE) with your provider. An ROE sets expectations and identifies stakeholders and factors such as testing timeframes, project targets, and any known limitations. Such a document will assign responsibilities and obligations.
- Make a plan for what to do with the report. At the end of the pen test, you’ll receive a full report that defines the existing vulnerabilities, if ePHI was breached, and how long a tester could remain inside your network without detection. Once you review the report, you must begin a remediation plan to address these issues. If the list is long, prioritize what to do first. Your pen test provider may also provide best practices and strategies to rectify weaknesses.
- Plan your next test. Pen testing isn’t a one-time exercise. You’ll need to conduct them at least annually, if not more often. Certain things can trigger the need to retest, including adding network infrastructure or applications, applying security patches, upgrading infrastructure or applications, modifying end-user policies, or establishing new locations.
Do You Need a HIPAA Penetration Test?
If you operate under HIPAA, you should consider pen testing as a regular part of your cybersecurity practices. Although you don’t need one to be compliant, it will improve your defense posture and reduce your risk of a breach.
We can help. We are experts at HIPAA pen testing and can provide every type of test. Contact us today for a free consultation.
HIPAA and Penetration Testing FAQs
Please schedule a 30-minute Discovery Session with us.
HIPAA identifiers serve various important purposes within the healthcare industry. These identifiers are essential for ensuring easy access to information to provide high-quality care services.
One key use of HIPAA identifiers is to balance protecting patient rights and enabling efficiency for covered entities. HIPAA compliance outlines specific circumstances where using and disclosing protected health information (PHI) without patient authorization is permissible. These circumstances include:
1. Conducting quality assessment and improvement activities: HIPAA identifiers allow healthcare organizations to assess and enhance patient care quality.
2. Developing clinical guidelines: With HIPAA identifiers, healthcare professionals can create evidence-based guidelines to promote efficient and effective medical practices.
3. Conducting patient safety activities per applicable regulations: HIPAA identifiers help perform activities that aim to ensure patient safety and adhere to relevant regulations.
4. Conducting population-based activities to improve health or reduce healthcare costs: By utilizing HIPAA identifiers, healthcare entities can engage in initiatives to improve public health or reduce healthcare expenses at a broader level.
5. Developing protocols: HIPAA identifiers enable the development of protocols that assist healthcare providers in delivering consistent and standardized care.
6. Conducting case management and care coordination: HIPAA identifiers facilitate effective case management and coordination of care among different healthcare professionals involved in a patient's treatment.
7. Contacting healthcare providers and patients to inquire about treatment alternatives: With the help of HIPAA identifiers, healthcare organizations can reach out to providers and patients to discuss alternative treatment options or gather additional information relevant to patient care.
8. Reviewing qualifications of healthcare professionals: HIPAA identifiers play a role in evaluating the qualifications and competence of healthcare professionals to ensure the delivery of high-quality care.
9. Evaluating the performance of healthcare providers or health plans: HIPAA identifiers assist in assessing the performance and effectiveness of healthcare providers and health plans to ensure optimal outcomes and patient satisfaction.
10. Conducting training programs or credentialing activities: Utilizing HIPAA identifiers, healthcare organizations can organize training programs and activities to enhance the skills and qualifications of healthcare professionals.
11. Supporting fraud and abuse detection and compliance programs: HIPAA identifiers aid in implementing fraud detection and compliance programs to safeguard against unlawful activities within the healthcare sector.
The "Wall of Shame" has faced criticism due to concerns over the way it handles organizations' cybersecurity breaches. Some argue that the portal tends to focus solely on the negative aspects of a breach, potentially causing long-term damage to a company's reputation. Critics suggest that the "Wall of Shame" fails to acknowledge or emphasize the positive steps that organizations may have taken to rectify their cybersecurity vulnerabilities after experiencing an incident. This lack of recognition for corrective actions and good-faith efforts to enhance cybersecurity practices could be seen as unfair and unbalanced in portraying organizations in the aftermath of a breach.
HIPAA, the Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act, is the cornerstone of patient privacy in the United States. It sets the standard for protecting sensitive patient data. Any entity covered by HIPAA must ensure the confidentiality, integrity, and availability of all the protected health information (PHI) it handles.
When there’s a breach, HIPAA requires these entities to report it, especially if it affects many individuals. That’s where the OCR Wall of Shame comes into play. It’s a transparency tool, showing the public how and where PHI breaches happen.
Furthermore, under the Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act (HIPAA), covered entities and their business associates are mandated to report any breaches to the Department of Health and Human Services’ (HHS) Office for Civil Rights (OCR). If the reported breach impacts more than 500 individuals, additional ramifications and consequences are triggered. This stringent regulation ensures that breaches are promptly reported and dealt with in accordance with HIPAA guidelines.
Under HIPAA, 18 identifiers classify data as Protected Health Information (PHI). These identifiers encompass a wide range of information that can be used to identify an individual. The list includes commonly recognized identifiers such as names, addresses, and social security numbers. However, it goes beyond these basic details and encompasses other data points like geographic information smaller than a state, dates (excluding year) related to an individual, phone numbers, fax numbers, email addresses, and more.
In addition to these, the list also includes less commonly known identifiers such as medical record numbers, health insurance beneficiary numbers, account numbers, certificate/license numbers, vehicle identifiers and serial numbers, device identifiers and serial numbers, web URLs, IP addresses, biometric identifiers like finger and voiceprints, and full-face photographic images. It even encompasses any unique identifying number, characteristic, or code associated with an individual.
By providing this comprehensive list, Your article ensures that all relevant and potential patient identifiers are covered. It offers a thorough understanding of PHI under HIPAA regulations, highlighting the importance of safeguarding these identifiers to protect patient privacy and confidentiality.
In the intricate landscape of healthcare data and privacy, understanding and correctly handling Protected Health Information (PHI) is crucial for adherence to regulations and preserving patient trust and safety. This is particularly vital in light of the Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act (HIPAA). Let's explore PHI, its 18 identifiers, the potential repercussions of non-compliance, and the specific data not considered a HIPAA identifier.
PHI encompasses any data in a healthcare context that can be used to identify an individual, combined with information about their health status, provision of healthcare, or payment for healthcare services. Under HIPAA, 18 identifiers classify data as PHI, including names, geographic information smaller than a state, dates (excluding year) related to an individual, phone numbers, fax numbers, email addresses, social security numbers, medical record numbers, health insurance beneficiary numbers, account numbers, certificate/license numbers, vehicle identifiers and serial numbers, device identifiers and serial numbers, web URLs, IP addresses, biometric identifiers like finger and voiceprints, full-face photographic images, and any unique identifying number, characteristic, or code.
However, it is important to note that not all data falls within the scope of HIPAA identifiers. De-identified data or health information that cannot be used to identify an individual or provide a reasonable base to identify them is not considered a HIPAA identifier. This type of data, known as de-identified data, does not fall within the 18 identifiers specified by HIPAA. Additionally, de-identified data has been determined by an expert using a statistical or scientific method to have a very low chance of being used individually or in combination with others to identify a person. As a result, HIPAA laws do not apply to de-identified data.
Understanding the distinction between PHI and de-identified data is essential for healthcare organizations and individuals who handle health information. It ensures compliance with HIPAA regulations and safeguards patient privacy while balancing the need for data utilization in healthcare research and analysis.
HIPAA, or the Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act, is a U.S. law designed to provide privacy standards to protect patients' medical records and other health information provided to health plans, doctors, hospitals, and other health care providers. Developed by the Department of Health and Human Services, these standards aim to improve the efficiency and effectiveness of the health care system.
Who Needs to Comply with HIPAA?
Covered Entities: This is the primary group that needs to adhere to HIPAA. They include:
- Health Plans: Insurance companies, health maintenance organizations (HMOs), employer-sponsored health plans, and government programs like Medicare and Medicaid.
- Healthcare Providers: This encompasses doctors, clinics, psychologists, dentists, chiropractors, nursing homes, and pharmacies that transmit health information in electronic form in connection with transactions for which HHS has adopted standards.
- Healthcare Clearinghouses: Entities that process nonstandard health information they receive from another entity into a standard format or vice versa.
Business Associates: These are individuals or entities that perform certain functions or activities that involve the use or disclosure of protected health information on behalf of, or provides services to, a covered entity. This could include consultants, billing companies, IT service providers like Blue Goat Cyber, especially when dealing with medical device security assessment and testing services, and others who have access to protected health information (PHI).
Common causes of data breaches in the healthcare industry include a significant number of breaches resulting from outside theft and considerable breaches being caused by internal mistakes or neglect. Insider mistakes leading to data breaches often involve mailing or email errors, such as employees clicking on phishing emails, forwarding emails with sensitive information to personal accounts, and accessing protected health information without authorization. These actions contribute to a notable portion of data breaches in the healthcare sector.
Penetration testing, also known as security testing, should be conducted on a regular basis to ensure the protection of organizations' digital assets. It is generally recommended that all organizations schedule security testing at least once a year. However, it is essential to conduct additional assessments in the event of significant infrastructure changes, prior to important events such as product launches, mergers, or acquisitions.
For organizations with large IT estates, high volumes of personal and financial data processing, or strict compliance requirements, more frequent pen tests are strongly encouraged. Such organizations should consider conducting penetration testing with a higher frequency to continually assess and strengthen their security measures.
To further enhance security practices, organizations can adopt agile pen testing or continuous pen testing. Unlike traditional pen testing, which occurs at specific intervals, agile pen testing integrates regular testing into the software development lifecycle (SDLC). This approach ensures that security assessments are conducted consistently throughout the development process, aligning with the release schedule of new features. By doing so, organizations can proactively address any vulnerabilities and mitigate risks to customers, without significantly impacting product release cycles.
Penetration Testing as a Service (PTaaS) is a dynamic approach to cybersecurity where regular and systematic penetration tests are conducted to assess the security of an organization's IT infrastructure. Unlike traditional penetration testing, which is typically performed as a one-time assessment, PTaaS offers ongoing testing and monitoring, allowing for continuous identification and remediation of vulnerabilities.
Key aspects of PTaaS include:
Regular Testing Cycles: PTaaS involves conducting penetration tests at predetermined intervals, such as monthly or quarterly. This regularity ensures that new or previously undetected vulnerabilities are identified and addressed promptly.
Updated Threat Intelligence: As cyber threats evolve rapidly, PTaaS providers stay abreast of the latest threat landscapes. This ensures that each test is relevant and effective against the most current types of attacks.
Continuous Improvement: By receiving regular feedback and insights from these tests, organizations can continually improve their security postures. This process includes patching vulnerabilities, updating security policies, and enhancing defense mechanisms.
Comprehensive Reporting and Support: PTaaS typically includes detailed reporting on the findings of each test, along with expert recommendations for remediation. Ongoing support and consultation are often part of the service to help organizations respond effectively to identified issues.
Cost-Effectiveness and Budget Predictability: With an annual contract and monthly payment options, PTaaS allows organizations to budget more effectively for their cybersecurity needs, avoiding the potentially higher costs of one-off penetration tests.
Cloud penetration testing is a specialized and crucial process involving comprehensive security assessments on cloud and hybrid environments. It is crucial to address organizations' shared responsibility challenges while using cloud services. Identifying and addressing vulnerabilities ensures that critical assets are protected and not left exposed to potential threats.
Cloud penetration testing involves simulating real-world attacks to identify and exploit vulnerabilities within the cloud infrastructure, applications, or configurations. It goes beyond traditional security measures by specifically targeting cloud-specific risks and assessing the effectiveness of an organization's security controls in a cloud environment.
The importance of cloud penetration testing lies in its ability to uncover security weaknesses that might be overlooked during regular security audits. As organizations increasingly adopt cloud services, they share the responsibility of ensuring the security of their data and assets with the cloud service provider. This shared responsibility model often poses challenges regarding who is accountable for various security aspects.
Cloud penetration testing not only helps in understanding the level of security provided by the cloud service provider but also provides insights into potential weaknesses within an organization's configurations or applications. By proactively identifying these vulnerabilities, organizations can take necessary steps to mitigate risks and strengthen their security posture.
These terms refer to the amount of information shared with the testers beforehand. Black box testing is like a real-world hacker attack where the tester has no prior knowledge of the system. It's a true test of how an actual attack might unfold. Gray box testing is a mix, where some information is given - this can lead to a more focused testing process. White box testing is the most thorough, where testers have full knowledge of the infrastructure. It's like giving someone the blueprint of a building and asking them to find every possible way in. Each type offers different insights and is chosen based on the specific testing objectives.
When choosing a pen test provider, you'll want to consider several important factors to ensure your organization's highest level of cybersecurity.
Selecting the right pen test provider is crucial for your organization's security. It's about identifying vulnerabilities and having a partner who can help you remediate them effectively. To make an informed decision, here's what you should look for:
Expertise and Certifications: One of the key factors to consider is the expertise of the pen testers. Look for providers with a team of experts holding certifications such as CISSP (Certified Information Systems Security Professional), CSSLP (Certified Secure Software Life Cycle Professional), OSWE (Offensive Security Web Expert), OSCP (Offensive Security Certified Professional), CRTE (Certified Red Team Expert), CBBH (Certified Bug Bounty Hunter), CRTL (Certified Red Team Lead), and CARTP (Certified Azure Red Team Professional). These certifications demonstrate a high level of knowledge and competence in the field.
Comprehensive Testing Services: The cybersecurity landscape constantly evolves, and threats are becoming more sophisticated. To stay ahead, you need a provider with expertise and resources to test your systems comprehensively. Look for a pen test provider like Blue Goat Cyber that offers testing across various areas, including internal and external infrastructure, wireless networks, web applications, mobile applications, network builds, and configurations. This ensures a holistic evaluation of your organization's security posture.
Post-Test Care and Guidance: Identifying vulnerabilities is not enough; you need a partner who can help you address them effectively. Consider what happens after the testing phase. A reputable pen test provider should offer comprehensive post-test care, including actionable outputs, prioritized remediation guidance, and strategic security advice. This support is crucial for making long-term improvements to your cybersecurity posture.
Tangible Benefits: By choosing a pen test provider like Blue Goat Cyber, you ensure that you receive a comprehensive evaluation of your security posture. This extends to various areas, including internal and external infrastructure, wireless networks, web and mobile applications, network configurations, and more. The expertise and certifications of their team guarantee a thorough assessment.
We follow a seven phase methodology designed to maximize our efficiency, minimize risk, and provide complete and accurate results. The overarching seven phases of the methodology are:
- Planning and Preparation
- Reconnaissance / Discovery
- Vulnerability Enumeration / Analysis
- Initial Exploitation
- Expanding Foothold / Post-Exploitation
- Cleanup
- Report Generation
An External Black-Box Penetration Test, also known as a Black Box Test, primarily focuses on identifying vulnerabilities in external IT systems that external attackers could exploit. This testing approach aims to simulate real-world attack scenarios, mimicking the actions of adversaries without actual threats or risks.
During an External Black-Box Pen Test, ethical hackers attempt to exploit weaknesses in network security from an external perspective. This form of testing does not involve internal assessments, which means it may provide a limited scope of insights. However, it is crucial to note that the absence of identified external vulnerabilities does not guarantee complete security.
To gain a comprehensive understanding of the network's resilience, it is recommended to complement the External Black-Box Pen Test with an Internal Black-Box Penetration Test. By combining both approaches, organizations can evaluate the effectiveness of their security measures from both external and internal perspectives.
It is important to acknowledge that external-facing devices and services, such as email, web, VPN, cloud authentication, and cloud storage, are constantly exposed to potential attacks. Therefore, conducting an External Black-Box Pen Test becomes imperative to identify any weaknesses that could compromise the network's confidentiality, availability, or integrity.
Organizations should consider performing External and Internal Black-Box Penetration Tests to ensure a robust security posture. This comprehensive approach allows for a thorough assessment of external vulnerabilities while uncovering potential internal risks. Organizations can strengthen their security defenses by leveraging these testing methodologies and proactively addressing identified weaknesses.
Blue Goat Cyber employs a comprehensive approach to gather intelligence for a penetration test. We begin by actively seeking out relevant information about the targets. This includes identifying the devices, services, and applications the targets utilize. In addition, Blue Goat Cyber meticulously explores potential valid user accounts and executes various actions to uncover valuable data. By conducting this meticulous information-gathering process, Blue Goat Cyber ensures we comprehensively understand the target's infrastructure and potential vulnerabilities for a successful penetration test.
Compliance penetration testing is specially designed to meet the requirements of various regulatory standards. For SOC 2, it's about ensuring that a company's information security measures are in line with the principles set forth by the American Institute of CPAs. In the case of PCI DSS, it's specifically for businesses that handle cardholder information, where regular pen testing is mandated to protect against data breaches. For medical devices regulated by the FDA, pen testing ensures that the devices and their associated software are safe from cyber threats. This type of testing is crucial not just for meeting legal requirements but also for maintaining the trust of customers and stakeholders in industries where data sensitivity is paramount.
