The following is a transcript of Christian Espinosa’s explanation of White Box Penetration Testing. Christian sold Alpine Security in 2020 and recently founded Blue Goat Cyber in 2022.
Hello, this is Christian Espinosa with Blue Goat Cyber. In this video, we’ll cover white box penetration tests. This completes our three video series on the different colored boxes of penetration test. We already did a video on the black and gray box penetration test.
With a white box penetration test, we know the most about the target. Just a quick review, with a black box, we know very little about the target other than the target’s IP address or URL. With a gray box, we know a little bit more than a black box. We often have user-level access to the target, such as a user-level account on a web application or an active directory user-level account. With the white box, though, we know the most about the target.
So sometimes, with the white box, we have root-level or administrator-level permissions. We also often have access to data flow diagrams, institute relationship diagrams, maybe even the source code, and maybe even access to the developers that are producing the software or developing the software or the product.
So typically, a white box penetration test is used during software or product development. It’s much more beneficial to have somebody from a penetration testing team working with your developers during the development process than waiting till your product is released and then hiring a penetration testing team to poke holes in it after it’s already been released. It costs a lot more money to fix it, and it’s much more difficult to fix after it’s been released. So that’s why the white box is typically done as part of the development cycle for products or software.
It can also be done or performed during system integration. Let’s say you’re a systems integrator, and you integrate different subsystems from different suppliers, and you integrate all that into your overall system. So you have to trust that your suppliers are designing their components to your specifications and that what you’re getting from them is secure.
So before you integrate that, or as you’re integrating that into your overall system, you should do some white box testing to ensure this component you get, for instance, only has the inputs and outputs you specified. No extraneous data is going through that component or originating from that component. So that would be an example of when we would do a white box penetration test for systems integration. Also, a white box penetration test typically includes a gray box and a black box because as we’re going through this process and looking at what’s being developed, we often do the tests from both the aspect of unauthenticated and user-level access, which is gray.
The threats we emulate for a white box; typically, we’re trying to discover poor coding practices. So a white box penetration test is typically performed during software development. So this is the prime time to discover an input validation problem or a balance checking problem. The perfect opportunity is during the development. As I mentioned earlier, if we wait to hire the penetration testing team until after development is done and they find out we have a problem, such as an input validation or a buffer overflow attack that our software allows to happen because of a vulnerability, that is much more costly to fix than if we could have identified it upfront.
The other threat the white box penetration test helps with is any issues in the supply chain. As we mentioned earlier, we often do white box penetration tests on a systems integrator. So if one of your suppliers and the supply chain has a vulnerability introduced somewhere along the supply chain and that component is mixed into your overall system, this is the perfect opportunity to test this before it’s released again to your customers.
If you have any questions about white box penetration testing, you can leave them as a comment beneath this video. If you want a white box penetration test, contact us. I hope you enjoyed this video, and I’ll talk to you later. Cheers!
White Box Penetration Testing FAQs
Please schedule a 30-minute Discovery Session with us so we can best understand your objectives.
The key features of Blue Goat Cyber's pentest service include:
-
Hacker-Style Methodology: This approach simulates an attacker's perspective, providing a realistic and comprehensive assessment of security vulnerabilities.
-
Comprehensive Testing: The service involves conducting over 2500 tests to identify and address a wide range of potential vulnerabilities across the system.
-
Detailed Remediation Guidance: Blue Goat Cyber offers in-depth remediation advice and strategies from experienced security engineers, helping clients effectively resolve vulnerabilities.
-
Remediation Validation Test: After vulnerabilities are addressed, a validation test is included to ensure that the remediations are effective and the issues have been properly resolved.
-
Post-Penetration Test Consultation: Clients benefit from a consultation call following the penetration test, where they can discuss results and gain further insights from Blue Goat Cyber's security experts.
These features collectively ensure that Blue Goat Cyber's pentest service not only identifies and assesses vulnerabilities but also aids in their effective resolution and confirms their mitigation, providing clients with a comprehensive understanding of their security posture.
White box testing techniques are used to verify the internal structure of a software product, focusing on the source code. Some common white box testing techniques include:
1. Statement Coverage: This technique involves testing each statement in the program to ensure logical correctness. It examines the program's building blocks to guarantee that they contribute to the expected behavior.
2. Decision Coverage: The program consists of various decisions, which are conditions that evaluate whether to be true or false. This technique involves testing each decision within the program to verify their accuracy. Decisions can involve comparisons between variables or between variables and constants.
3. Path Coverage: Path coverage aims to test all possible paths in a program from start to finish. A path refers to a sequence of statements or decisions leading to a specific program location. This technique ensures that all potential execution paths are explored, validating the program's behavior under different circumstances.
4. Branch Coverage: Similar to decision coverage, branch coverage tests all possible branches within the program. A branch represents different outcomes resulting from a decision or a set of decisions. By covering all branches, this technique helps ensure that the program handles each possible decision outcome correctly.
5. Condition Coverage: This technique involves testing all possible combinations of conditions within a decision. It examines how various combinations of conditions affect the program's execution. Considering all conditions helps identify potential errors or unexpected behavior that may arise due to specific combinations.
6. Loop Coverage: Loops are an integral part of many programs. This technique thoroughly tests the loop structures, including the execution of the loop body zero, once, and multiple times. It ensures that the program handles loops correctly and handles boundary conditions appropriately.
7. Data Flow Coverage: This technique tests the flow of data within the program. It involves analyzing how variables are assigned values, used, or altered throughout the program's execution. Covering different data flows helps detect potential anomalies or issues related to data manipulation.
8. Time and State Coverage: This technique involves testing the program's behavior with respect to time and its internal state. It aims to validate how the program handles changes in time, such as delays or time-dependent events, as well as variations in its internal state. This technique ensures the program maintains correct behavior under different temporal and state-based conditions.
By employing these white box testing techniques, software developers and testers can ensure their software products' internal correctness, logic, and robustness.
White box penetration testing is critical for enhancing software or product security. Testers have root or administrator-level access in this approach, granting deep insight into the system, including data flow, relationship diagrams, and source code. This deep analysis can reveal hidden vulnerabilities.
Having a penetration testing team work alongside developers during software development is invaluable. It saves time and costs by identifying and fixing security flaws early, preventing expensive post-release fixes. White box testing targets issues like poor coding practices and input validation errors, ensuring a secure software foundation.
This testing also extends to the broader supply chain, identifying vulnerabilities introduced by systems integrators or suppliers. By addressing these early, it protects not just your data but also your customers' sensitive information.
Blue Goat Cyber's white box penetration testing methodology is thorough and multi-phased, offering deep insights into the target system. Unlike black or gray box testing, it gives testers extensive access, including root-level permissions, critical resources like data flow and institute relationship diagrams, and sometimes the source code. This level of access allows for a detailed analysis and identification of vulnerabilities.
The methodology consists of several phases:
- Planning and Preparation: Setting clear objectives, scope, and rules of engagement.
- Reconnaissance/Discovery: Gathering extensive information about the target.
- Vulnerability Enumeration/Analysis: Using tools and manual methods, identifying and analyzing potential vulnerabilities.
- Initial Exploitation: Prioritizing and exploiting identified vulnerabilities.
- Expanding Foothold/Deeper Penetration: Using compromised systems to find and exploit further vulnerabilities.
- Cleanup: Removing all traces of the testing process.
- Report Generation: Documenting the findings and providing detailed remediation guidance.
By incorporating this methodology, especially early in software development, Blue Goat Cyber ensures comprehensive vulnerability identification and resolution, significantly enhancing system security.
White Box Testing has several drawbacks:
-
Limited Perspective: Testers may be biased due to their in-depth knowledge of the application's internals, potentially overlooking some issues.
-
Programming Knowledge Requirement: It demands significant programming skills, such as understanding port scanning and SQL injection, to explore internal networks and identify vulnerabilities.
-
Time-Consuming: This detailed testing process takes more time and effort than Black Box Testing, making it less suitable for projects with tight deadlines.
-
Resource-Intensive: It requires access to source code and close collaboration with developers, demanding more coordination and resources.
-
Dependence on Internal Implementation: Heavily reliant on the internal implementation, this testing might miss underlying issues or vulnerabilities, and it can overlook critical user experience flaws.
-
Complex Systems Challenge: White Box Testing becomes more challenging and error-prone with complex systems, as understanding and analyzing intricate architectures is difficult.
While providing insights into specific vulnerabilities and the internal workings of applications, White Box Testing's limitations, like narrow testing perspective, need for programming expertise, time and resource intensity, dependence on internal implementation, and difficulties with complex systems, must be considered when choosing a testing strategy.
White-box penetration testing assesses a system, network, or application's security with access to internal information. Common tools used in this process include:
-
Metasploit: A framework for developing and validating exploit code, simulating attacks, and testing network security.
-
Nmap: An open-source tool for network scanning, auditing, and identifying security weaknesses, offering detailed packet and scan-level analysis.
-
Burp Suite: A comprehensive tool for web application testing, including features for scanning, intercepting requests, and analyzing vulnerabilities.
-
Wireshark: An open-source network traffic analyzer for capturing and inspecting data packets, identifying network issues, and investigating suspicious activities.
-
Zap (OWASP ZAP): An open-source web application security scanner for automated vulnerability scanning and penetration testing.
-
SonarQube: An open-source platform for static code analysis, identifying coding vulnerabilities and security flaws in the source code.
-
OWASP Dependency-Check: A tool for scanning application dependencies to identify known vulnerabilities in libraries.
-
Nikto: An open-source web server scanner that tests web hosts for vulnerabilities, misconfigurations, and outdated software.
Each of these tools addresses specific aspects of security testing, offering valuable insights to ensure the security and integrity of the tested system or application.
Penetration testing varies in forms: white, black, and gray. White box testing offers deep target knowledge, surpassing even the developers' understanding, allowing for informed testing decisions. On the other hand, black box testing provides minimal information, often just the IP address or URL, relying on external observations. Gray box testing is a middle ground, offering some access like user-level accounts but with limited and possibly outdated information. Each type serves different needs, with the white box providing comprehensive insight, the black box minimal information, and the gray box a balance of the two.
Wireshark is essential in white box penetration testing for analyzing network traffic and assessing system security. It enables real-time monitoring and capturing of traffic, offering insights into device, protocol, and application communications. This tool helps identify vulnerabilities, security weaknesses, and suspicious activities by analyzing network packets. Testers can pinpoint unauthorized access, unencrypted channels, and potential security breaches. Wireshark's filtering and search capabilities allow focusing on specific data, aiding in identifying exploits. It also provides statistics and graphical views of network patterns, helping assess performance issues like bottlenecks and latency. In summary, Wireshark is invaluable for in-depth network analysis, vulnerability identification, security assessment, and performance evaluation in white box penetration testing.
The primary purpose of John the Ripper in white box penetration testing is to act as a fast password cracker compatible with various operating systems such as Unix, Windows, DOS, BeOS, and OpenVMS. Its main objective is to identify weak Unix passwords. It supports a wide range of password hash types commonly used in Unix environments, including crypt(3) hashes and additional ones like Kerberos AFS and Windows NT/2000/XP/2003 LM hashes. John the Ripper also benefits from various contributed patches that expand its capability to crack passwords effectively.
Nmap, a key open-source tool for network administration, is essential in white box penetration testing. It helps in detailed network analysis and vulnerability identification, offering insights into network hosts and services. This is crucial for understanding potential security weaknesses and setting a baseline for security audits.
In white box testing, where complete system knowledge is available, Nmap's thorough scans of network configurations, open ports, and services are invaluable. It detects misconfigurations, weak access controls, and other exploitable flaws. Nmap also monitors network connections, identifying real-time threats and unauthorized activities and enhancing intrusion detection.
Its open-source and cost-free nature makes Nmap accessible to all security professionals, ensuring comprehensive security assessments are not limited by budget.
Metasploit is a versatile tool in penetration testing, primarily used for developing and validating exploit code. It allows testers to create and evaluate vulnerabilities in a controlled environment, assessing their impact on targeted systems or networks.
Additionally, Metasploit offers a broad range of modules and exploits for testing network security. Testers can simulate various attack scenarios to uncover network vulnerabilities, leading to proactive security enhancements.
The tool also enables the assessment of remote computer security, allowing testers to target and potentially compromise systems remotely. This simulates real-world threats from external actors.
White Box Penetration Testing demands in-depth programming knowledge. Testers need expertise in various languages like Java, Python, C++, and SQL since the testing targets the internal network. They should be skilled in port scanning to find network vulnerabilities and understand SQL injection techniques for exploiting database system weaknesses.
Additionally, knowledge of attacks like cross-site scripting (XSS), cross-site request forgery (CSRF), and remote code execution (RCE) is vital. Testers must also grasp the inner workings of programming frameworks, libraries, and web technologies, including how to exploit their vulnerabilities.
This comprehensive programming and attack knowledge enables testers to effectively assess and enhance the security of the internal network, identifying vulnerabilities and recommending countermeasures.
